skip to Main Content

Managers and Leaders: What’s the Difference?

Business Leadership  

Take a moment to consider a wonderful leader that you have met in your life.

That person could be a famous personality, perhaps a Martin Luther King, a Mahatma Gandhi, a Ronald Reagan, or a John F. Kennedy.

Perhaps the leader that you are imagining right now is a father, a mother, a family member or a friend.

That person might also be a mentor, a business leader, or a spiritual figure.

The image in your mind’s eye is likely to stir emotions, make you happy, and kindle a passion. It’s OK to linger here for a minute or two and enjoy the moment.

Now, think of a great manager whom you have encountered.

That is a little more difficult an assignment, isn’t it?

You might be able to remember a few good managers, and maybe you have even patterned your management style to emulate them. But good managers are not as likely to invoke the same emotional response in people as a great leader. In fact, it might even be difficult to think of a past or current manager as being especially “great.” Maybe they were simply competent.

The purpose of this post is not to disparage good managers. The world needs more good managers. And while it is virtuous to remember and celebrate great leaders, not everyone can be a great leader. After all, if we were all great leaders, who would there be to follow? There are appropriate times and places for both leaders and managers to contribute to the company’s mission.

If one were to envision a Venn diagram, with managers on one side and leaders on the other, there would surely be an area where the two circles intersect. Some managers are leaders, but not all good managers are good leaders. Some leaders are managers, but not all leaders are good managers. Ideally, an individual will embody attributes of both, but a person can be very effective in their work either way.

Supply chain management is a relatively new business concept that was born in the 1980’s and was popularized in the 1990’s. Its wonderful contribution is that it looks at businesses holistically. SCM recognizes the interconnected nature of individual activities. It seeks to break down barriers to communication between functional silos and promote cross-functional strategy development. Great leaders are emerging as SCM matures as a profession.

Here are five differences between managers and leaders.

1. Managers require. Leaders inspire.

College textbooks often define management in terms of what managers do: they plan, implement, and control. Planning might involve a level of creative thought and strategy development, but for the manager, it is frequently in support of larger company-wide objectives. The latter two responsibilities of managers imply a high degree of transactional preoccupation. Implementation and control are “sweating the details.” They involve working out the background logistics that bring an idea into reality. It’s often difficult work that is infrequently celebrated. Managers develop standard operating procedures and enforce compliance. They measure, monitor, and take corrective action as they go.

Leaders tend to consider the broader picture. They look at businesses holistically, with long-term objectives always in mind. They assemble teams of skilled practitioners, inspiring them to work together toward achieving those objectives. While leaders do worry about the details, they will often encourage their team to resolve those details themselves, empowering their followers to act, always in the best interests of the business.

2. Managers tell. Leaders sell.

Managers tend to be directive. They understand best practices and tell their subordinates how to fit their work into those practices. They enforce rules and regulations. They ensure that subordinates are well aware of how things should be done.

Leaders are more concerned with an idea. They motivate others to buy into that idea. They focus on the “why” and the “what” of an opportunity. Leaders understand that they might not have all of the answers on how something gets done efficiently, but they rely upon their tribe to seek answers to the “how” questions. Leaders are great communicators, who are able to verbalize the reasons why their team should devote their time and energy to bringing the leader’s idea to fruition.  

3. Managers work the Mission. Leaders shape the Vision.

Every strategic plan has a mission statement. It defines what a company does. It articulates a business’s purpose and what it intends to contribute to society. Using a sports analogy, the Mission defines what arena the company intends to compete within.

Mission statements set up the four walls within which a company should operate. It provides focus and consistency of purpose. The Mission is an important tool that gets people working consistently.

The Vision, on the other hand, articulates the long-term direction of the company. It lights a beacon, sometimes far off on the horizon, that answers the question “where is it that we, as a company, want to go.” A properly crafted Vision statement appeals to one’s emotions. It is a “call to action.” It motivates and endures. It sustains commitment over the long term and gives employees a reason to take pride in their company.

4. Managers calculate. Leaders speculate.

A significant portion of the manager’s role is to monitor and control activities. They are often very deeply involved in developing key performance indicators and managing performance both internally (for example, of employees and production systems) and externally (for example, with respect to improving supplier delivery and quality performance.)

Leaders often consider the “what if.” What if we expand into new markets? What if we develop a new product? What if we build a revolutionary distribution system? Responsible speculation on such matters requires a great deal of courage and willingness to break new ground. Leaders are also courageous enough to seek good counsel from trusted advisors, who might eventually be charged with the responsibility of motivating the company to blaze new trails.

5. Managers are about efficiency. Leaders are about effectiveness.

It is often said that efficiency is about doing something right. Effectiveness is about doing the right thing.

To their credit, good managers seek ways to make the machinery of the business enterprise work as efficiently as possible. They use objective measurements to try to deliver results with the least amount of time, effort, and resource. Increases in productivity of a system is a common goal. Efficiency focuses on processes and how to improve them.   

But the leader who focuses on effectiveness is less concerned about cost and is more concerned about the goal. The leader’s attention is on the future, whereas the manager’s attention dwells in the present. The leader seeks innovation and new ways to achieve the vision. The leader motivates the team to stay pointed in the right direction, pulling together. They are willing to encourage change and are tolerant of appropriate risk. They are liberal with giving credit and reluctant to punish. They understand that conflict is inevitable, and facilitate discussion and consensus. They enthusiastically develop followers and other leaders, always growing the tribe.

For a successful business, efficiency and effectiveness are two sides to the same coin. Companies who thrive over the long term are able to lever the planning, implementation, and control expertise of a good management team while engaging the visionary power of great leaders. It is the perfect combination.

Contact us if you would like to learn how DemandCaster can help you end the chaos and reap the benefits of an agile, supply chain planning process.

Related Articles

Supply Chain Planning in the Face of Rapid Change

There’s little that could properly prepare the world for the magnitude of global events such as the COVID-19 global pandemic. These situations not only impact us as individuals, but often highlight critical vulnerabilities in our business processes. Supply chain planning [...]

Data and the leadership mindset

Lou Rassey says that data is an asset and it should be seen as such. He also noted that there are three key parts to the right mindset of a successful leader in this transitional time. Good leaders should have [...]

Why good leaders are trustworthy

Transformation within industries or businesses works best when employees trust their leaders. However, many leaders make the mistake of just asking their employees to trust them instead of building a solid base. If you want to build that trust, demonstrate [...]

Traits that define a good leader in the manufacturing industry

What do successful leaders in the manufacturing industry have in common? First of all, their employees trust them. How do you build that trust? Industry Week said, “It requires the real work of building a culture around teamwork, creativity and [...]

How to advance your career in demand planning

How do you advance your career in demand planning? First you need to know the language. That might sound simple - you already use it every day! However, different companies and areas use different terminology to take the time to [...]

Embracing change starts with you

Change is necessary for a business to grow and develop. However, you can’t change the way that people think or a company’s culture overnight. Industry Week said, “Leaders should try to change how people act in the organization by defining [...]

Building efficiency through teamwork

Dave Turbide said, “The very essence of supply chain management is coordinated activity; working together to move the materials and products through the chain from source to manufacturing, from manufacturing through the distribution network, and out to the customer in [...]

Some ways you can manage the talent shortage

There is a current shortage in manufacturing labor, so businesses are getting creative! One way you can retain talent is by convincing retirement-aged workers to stay with incentives. You could also increase talent by partnering with a school to create [...]

Which kinds of leaders should encourage a growth mindset?

Bill Joiner claims there are five types of leaders; experts, achievers, and catalyst leaders. Experts have passion for what they do and problem solving skills but tend to not seek feedback from their employees enough. Achievers are typically more collaborative [...]

The Human Factor in Manufacturing

Reports that say robots are taking over jobs in manufacturing aren’t accounting for “the human factor.” In fact, Industry Week reported that humans perform 72% of tasks in manufacturing. They said, “Humans are and will remain integral to the manufacturing [...]
Subscribe to our Blog
Back To Top