skip to Main Content

Unconstrained Forecast or Constrained Forecast? Why do they matter?

S&OP  
07/07/2015

When it comes to Sales and Operations Planning,  stakeholders at all levels can sometimes find it hard to understand different concepts and the important underlying strategy involved. One of the most important topics I have found in the S&OP process that seems to drive people crazy is The Unconstrained Sales Forecast vs. The Constrained Sales Forecast.  The quick explanation is, the start of your S&OP process is an Unconstrained Forecast and the byproduct of your S&OP process is a constrained forecast.

The unconstrained forecast can be confusing to some. The unconstrained forecast is based off the true demand potential that exist when running your forecast with no consideration given to constraints that may exist, such as capacity, materials, cash-flow,etc. The constrained forecast is a forecast constrained by the operations side of the business such as capacity, materials, cash-flow, etc.

A simple example of an unconstrained forecast is: "We only have capacity for 500,000 light bulbs per month. If I have demand signals for 1 million light bulbs per month my unconstrained forecast will show 1 million light bulbs per month."

So, now that we understand what the unconstrained forecast is, why is it important, especially considering the final plan in the S&OP process after being vetted through the supply side will end as a constrained plan that is a reflection of what can actually be achieved. So why waste your time playing pretend and imagining we live in some perfect world where we have no limitations?

Just because your unconstrained forecast gets chopped down to reality, a mature S&OP process will keep the unconstrained forecast as a valuable resource to present to the executive team, in the Executive S&OP meeting. A note on this, be cautious you avoid confusion of people thinking multiple plans are floating around, by the time you are in the Executive S&OP meeting your Constrained forecast is the plan.

Why present the unconstrained forecast to the executive team? Let’s bring everything together now and talk about strategy. Using the lighting company I mentioned earlier, lets assume that the unconstrained forecast reflects 1 million units of light bulbs per month, but you are constrained to 500,000 units a month. The S&OP process has now set the stage for the executive team to easily be alerted to the 500,000 units of potential lost sales per month. Knowing this information should trigger the executive team to implement a strategic plan to increase capacity and handle the constraint hurdles. Below is a visual to help.

So, why is the unconstrained forecast so important? It is the key signal your executive team needs to plan for the future. The executives now have the information to decide if they need to build more manufacturing plants, raise capital, re-negotiate with vendors, hire more employees, etc. On the flip side to this, there may also be the situation where your unconstrained forecast is too low, this will give your executive team the information to make serious decisions in the business such as reduction in force, plant closures, and re-evaluating current sales strategies.

Related Articles

Are you considering customer service?

Customer service should be part of S&OP. While many businesses don't include customer service in the process flow, they should! Quality communication and collaboration with those in your business that are part of customer service can streamline planning initiatives. They [...]

Why you need more than just data

Is just having data good enough? Absolutely not!  You need to be able to use all that data to make informed decisions.  IndustryWeek said, "Analytics have the potential to totally reconfigure the factory, but they must be utilized in every [...]

Sales and Operations Execution for the Short Term

One current problem in supply chain is with short term execution. Sales and operations planning usually looks ahead at least three months, so the short term is where S&OE comes in. Supply Chain Digital said, “S&OE fits within the immediate [...]

Why does your business need S&OP

S&OP is valuable for businesses because it helps in planning for the future. When done well, it can help your business to grow and succeed.  Forbes said, "A more effective and holistic S&OP process goes straight to the heart of [...]

What is S&OP all about?

When it comes down to the basics, what is S&OP all about? To start, it stands for sales and operations planning.  Hubspot said, "The S&OP process includes forecasting, demand and supply planning, and executive review. The goal is to coordinate [...]

Is S&OP owned by supply chain?

S&OP is commonly under supply chain, but should it be? The Institute of Business Forecasting & Planning said, “As S&OP maturity evolves the requirement for ownership of the process becomes more and more focused on business leadership and decision-making.” It [...]

Why you should be using an S&OP Calendar

Do you use your S&OP calendar? It is a great tool to help you meet your goals and work together. The Institute of Business Forecasting & Planning noted, “By consistently indicating where they contribute in the process, and indicating that [...]

Working on your S&OP tech

Technology can be instrumental in bettering your sales and operations planning. The APQC blog said, “Specific industries are adopting technology such as AI and data analytics to address planning challenges, which indicates a critical competitive shift other organizations will soon [...]

S&OP vs. SIOP: What’s the Difference?

From one perspective, there is very little difference between “sales and operations planning (S&OP)” and “sales, inventory, and operations planning (SIOP)” because the overall objective is the same for both: Get the right inventory to the right place at the [...]

Seven Advantages of Integrated Demand and Supply Planning

A championship football team reaches such heights because of teamwork, practice, and a clear strategy.  Both offensively and defensively, team members are drilled over and over to work together and know the plan so that on game day, everyone is [...]
Subscribe to our Blog
Back To Top